A Mosaic of Wings (Kimberly Duffy) – Review

Posted 29 June 2020 by Katie in Christian Fiction, Historical, Review, Romance / 0 Comments


Title: 
A Mosaic of Wings
Author: 
Kimberly Duffy
Genre: 
Historical Romance
Publisher: 
Bethany House
Release date: 
5 May 2020
Pages: 
368

PURCHASE AT

Amazon US  |  Amazon AU
iTunes  |  Koorong  |  Barnes & Noble

A Mosaic of Wings


About the Book

It’s 1885, and all Nora Shipley wants, now that she’s graduating from Cornell University as valedictorian of the entomology program, is to follow in her late father’s footsteps by getting her master’s degree and taking over the scientific journal he started. The only way to uphold her father’s legacy is to win a scholarship, so she joins a research expedition in Kodaikanal, India, to prove herself in the field.

India isn’t what she expects, though, and neither is the rival classmate who accompanies her, Owen Epps. As her preconceptions of India–and of Owen–fall away, she finds both far more captivating than she expected. Forced by the expedition leader to stay at camp and illustrate exotic butterflies the men of the team find without her, Nora befriends Sita, a young Indian girl who has been dedicated to a goddess against her will.

In this spellbinding new land, Nora is soon faced with impossible choices–between saving Sita and saving her career, and between what she’s always thought she wanted and the man she’s come to love.

Excerpt

Nora climbed until she thought she’d reached the height where the monarchs had gathered. Then she inched forward, pressed her body against the tree, and swung her foot to the next branch over. With her feet firmly planted on two different branches, she piano-keyed her fingers around the trunk until she could shift her weight full to the second branch. She ignored Rose’s gasps punctuating the silence and repeated the process until she stood only inches from the kaleidoscope of butterflies.
    She wished she had her sketchbook. Instead, she committed the visual to memory, their brilliant segmented wings reminding her that her father often said nature displayed the artistry of God. She couldn’t disagree. She didn’t think any museum held a more beautiful display of creativity. Every insect she studied, every bug she duplicated in watercolor and pencil, pointed her toward a God who loved beauty. And she loved being outside admiring it.
    If you take over the journal, you’ll spend too much time at a desk.
    Nora ignored the thought and reached to brush her fingertip across one silken wing. Her father’s dream was worth the sacrifice.
    “Nora!” Rose’s shout pierced the silence. “Get down here before you kill yourself!”
    As a group, the butterflies lifted from the tree. They surrounded Nora in a cloud, tickling her ears and scalp with their fluttering wings. She laughed, then quickly closed her mouth when she felt them brush her lips, as soft as Chantilly lace. She steadied herself on the branch and slowly, with gentle movements, lifted her arms above her head. The monarchs crisscrossed around her in a sunrise-hued blanket. Then they lifted into the sky and flew northward.
    For a moment, Nora didn’t move. Her arms still raised, she listened to herself breathe and followed the flight of the butterflies as they disappeared from view.
    “Did you see that?” she called to Bitsy and Rose.
    “Incredible” Bitsy answered, shielding her eyes and looking up at her.
    Rose wrung her hands. “Please, now, won’t you come down? There’s someone coming.”
    Nora looked past the tree and saw a rowboat making a lazy path toward them. She sighed and began her climb down. When she reached the halfway point, someone called out to them. Nora strained to see over a tree branch obscuring her view. Standing on her toes, she just made out the little boat and a man’s straw hat.
    She didn’t know how it happened. She’d been climbing trees since she could walk, but for the first time in her life, she found herself slipping off the branch that snugged her against the trunk. She flipped over, scraping her cheek against the rough bark. With only enough time to recognize Rose’s shriek, she dropped through the air.

Review

To open the pages of this novel is to enter another world—a world of insects and butterflies, of sticky heat, rich new aromas, and confronting customs, and of a passionate young female scientist struggling to prove herself in a male-dominated field. It was obvious the author has not only done her research, but experienced India for herself (albeit in more modern times!), and from that aspect, it truly was a pleasure to read this novel and immerse myself in another time and place.

When it came to the heroine, however, I found myself frustrated, more often than not, by the way she conducted herself, which put a dampener on my reading experience. I could sympathise with her on the loss of her father and her need to repeatedly prove herself in a field dominated by men, but she didn’t do herself any favours. She made it more than clear that Lucius (her step-father) could never take the place of her father. And no, he may not have won any step-father of the year awards, but there was no graciousness in her behaviour toward him either. And while she may have been a very capable entomologist, her determination to prove herself in India often led her to make choices that only reinforced the idea that women were a liability in the field rather than a help. At the very least, I would have like to have seen her mature in these aspects by the end of the novel, but I didn’t see any evidence of that in the story.

The hero, on the other hand, I grew quite fond of. It may have helped that there was a bit of a Gilbert Blythe vibe about him! To his credit, he stood by Nora, even when she got into messes of her own making, but while I’m all for a hero who loves unconditionally and supports the heroine in achieving her dreams, I couldn’t help feeling that Nora would have benefitted even more from someone who could take her in hand, perhaps even stand up to her for her own good, when necessary.

Despite not having connected with this heroine as much as I would have liked, there was much to enjoy about this story, and I’m keen to see what’s next from this author.

I received a copy of this novel from the publisher. This has not influenced the content of my review, which is my honest and unbiased opinion.

About the Author

Kimberly Duffy is a Long Island native currently living in Southwest Ohio. When she’s not homeschooling her four kids, she writes historical fiction that takes her readers back in time and across oceans. She loves trips that require a passport, recipe books, and practicing kissing scenes with her husband of 20 years. He doesn’t mind. 

Connect with Kimberly:
Website  |  Facebook  |  Instagram  |  Pinterest

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.