The Truth About Romantic Comedies (Sean C. McMurray) – Review

Posted 28 March 2019 by Katie in Christian Fiction, Humour, Review, Romance, Young Adult / 3 Comments


Title: 
The Truth About Romantic Comedies
Author: 
Sean C. McMurray
Genre: 
YA/Romantic Comedy
Publisher: 
Anaiah Press
Release date: 
15 January 2019
Pages: 
312

PURCHASE AT

Amazon US  |  Amazon AU

The Truth about Romantic Comedies


About the Book

Sixteen-year-old Timothy Gephart’s life is a chronicle of loser-hood. Trapped by the decaying walls of his family’s trailer and saddled with the responsibility of caring for a grandmother stricken with a wicked combination of Alzheimer’s and cancer, Timothy isn’t exactly thriving in the teenage chapter of his life. To make matters worse, his girlfriend inexplicably dumps him through a text message. Heartbroken, Tim drives his grandmother to and from her radiation treatments as if the last page of his life has already been written. And then the enigmatic Rachel Wilson struts into the cancer center’s waiting room.

Self-proclaimed social scientist Rachel Wilson hasn’t reconciled herself to her mother’s cancer, but she’s doing her best to stay positive…and distracted. With his dry wit and easy acceptance of her bright blue hair, Timothy might be the answer to a prayer Rachel hasn’t had the strength to ask. As a fast friendship blossoms into something more, Timothy and Rachel learn that Rachel’s father’s job will soon take her family to a new life across the country. Knowing that their time together is running out, Timothy and Rachel go all in on an experiment that will put every romantic comedy cliche to the test, to say nothing of the foundation on which their relationship was built. Happily-ever-after has never been so hard.

Excerpt

Context: Tim is sitting in the waiting room at Kutcher Cancer Center reading the only memento from his recently ended relationship— “a dog-eared paranormal romance about vampires and the nubile young girls who love them.”

A girl, of the un-undead variety, plops down in the chair beside me. She has a pixie cut that has been dyed a bright purple. I didn’t see her come in.
    “That book should come with a warning,” the girl says.
    I stare blankly at her for a second. “What?”
    “That book should come with a warning. Like the ones on cigarette cartons.”
    “Why?” I turn the book over, but the back cover is only a blurb and an ISBN number. No warning label.
    She sits back. “Young girls have gotten crazy ideas from such books, you know. All sorts of foolish notions of love and romance and wishes fulfilled without collateral damage.”
    “Really?” I say, brows raised in mock surprise. “They’re fantasy, i.e.; not real. Anyway, I’m a dude. I guess I’m immune.”
    She fakes a sigh of relief and wipes invisible perspiration off her brow. “Phew! You had me worried there. I thought you were a moldable young girl.”
    My attention returns to the page. A few moments later the un-undead girl interrupts me.
    “If you don’t mind me asking, why are you reading that? I could be wrong, but I’m not sure you’re in the author’s target audience.”
    Why am I reading this book? In hopes of some kind of cosmic connection to my ex-girlfriend that will convince her she made the worst mistake of her life? I can’t tell this girl that. She seems like the kind of person who would accept that kind of explanation without question, but still…
    “Homework assignment,” I say.
    She looks skeptical but doesn’t press the matter. “Where do you go to school?”
    “Starling High.”
    “Really? I live in Starling,” she says with a tiny bit of excitement.
    “I don’t think I’ve seen you at school.” There’s no think about it. I haven’t seen her. You can’t miss a bright purple pixie cut.
    “I don’t go to Starling High School. I go to Starling Christian Academy,” she says.
    “Oh.” Are they even allowed to read vampire novels at her school?
    She straightens her back and folds her hands—black nail polish with tiny specks of purple glitter—in her lap. “You seem surprised. Do you find me unbecoming of a Christian school attendee?”
    I shrug. “Well, the purple hair and everything…”
    “There isn’t a commandment against dying your hair.”
    “Are you sure? I think it was the eleventh.” I clear my throat and do my best Moses impression. “Thou shalt not dye thy hair.”
    She laughs again. I could totally get used to her laugh.

What a delightfully surprising novel! Fresh, funny, and unexpectedly poignant.

Review: The Truth About Romantic Comedies Tweet

Review

What a delightfully surprising novel! This was fresh, funny, unexpectedly poignant towards the end, and once I’d picked it up I had a hard time putting it down. One of the biggest reasons for that was Timothy’s voice. (A) He’s a teenage male—big originality points; (B) The characterisation was spot on; and (C) The humour was effortlessly dry, droll, and self-deprecating. It was an addictive combination, and it only became more so when he was with Rachel or his best mate Brandon.

One of the other attractions of this novel was the relaxed nature of the relationship that developed between Timothy and Rachel. Even when their friendship developed into romance, it still retained its relaxed feel—helped no doubt by the quirkiness of their interactions. It was just right for a teenage relationship and a young adult audience.

I also liked the way this story plants spiritual seeds. Timothy isn’t a Christian at the beginning of this novel but he begins to think about what that would mean to him through his interactions with Rachel and their trip to the Midwestern Christian Youth Life Convention. There’s no Bible bashing and no conversion scene (although it’s implied by the end that Tim is at least taking steps towards making such a decision, if he hasn’t already) but the story brings the grace of God front and centre—not just His grace towards us, but the way in which we can reflect His grace in our relationship with others.

And that ending . . . well, one part in particular. It brings up a very relevant issue for teens, and once I got there I could see how it had been subtly foreshadowed throughout the story. It doesn’t dwell on the subject, just says what needs to be said and moves the story to its conclusion, but I think the simplicity with which it was handled—at a moment where the story has already taken a poignant turn—is exactly what will draw teens in to think about the characters’ actions and responses long after the story is finished.

Even if you’re not normally a YA reader, I think you’ll find plenty to enjoy in this story. I certainly did.

I received a copy of this novel from the author. This has not influenced the content of my review, which is my honest and unbiased opinion.

About the Author

Sean C. McMurray (1984-present) grew up on the mean rural roads of southwestern Ohio where he honed his storytelling skills on anyone willing to listen. Now he does it professionally as an author and history teacher. Sean still lives in rural Ohio with the love of his life and his favorite audience, their three little children.

Connect with Sean:  Website  |  Facebook  |  Twitter

3 responses to “The Truth About Romantic Comedies (Sean C. McMurray) – Review

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.